Manchester United boss Ruben Amorim has confirmed that Altay Bayindir will start in goal for Sunday’s Manchester derby against Manchester City. The decision comes despite the club’s recent signing of Senne Lammens and the departure of André Onana on loan to Trabzonspor.
Bayindir, 27, has been United’s starting goalkeeper in all three Premier League games so far this season. His performances, while not without mistakes, have convinced Amorim that his experience is essential for big games as the team navigates a difficult period.
A Changing of Guards
André Onana, who was previously United’s first choice, has moved to Turkish side Trabzonspor on loan after a shaky run of form. Onana’s standout errors, particularly in a League Cup upset against lower-league Grimsby Town, undermined confidence in his consistency.
At the same time, United bolstered their goalkeeping options by signing Senne Lammens from Royal Antwerp for approximately £18.2 million. Although Lammens is a highly rated young keeper, Amorim has made clear that Bayindir will remain first choice for this match. The manager cited the importance of experience under pressure, especially in high-stakes games like the derby.
Amorim also revealed that United looked at signing Emiliano Martínez, but opted in the end for Lammens because of his potential over the longer term.
Injuries Add to the Stakes
United will head into the derby missing several key players. Forward Matheus Cunha, midfielder Mason Mount, and defender Diogo Dalot are all sidelined with injuries. No firm return dates have been given for any of them, though all are reported to be working hard on their recovery. Amorim said their statuses will be assessed day by day.
What This Means for Bayindir and United
The decision to stick with Bayindir is a vote of confidence. Despite criticism from some quarters over his errors—for example misjudging a corner against Arsenal—Amorim appears to believe that Bayindir has the character and experience to handle the heat.
For Lammens, this is still clearly part of a long-term plan. He is viewed as an investment for the future, meaning that while he may not start this derby, he is expected to push Bayindir and keep the competition for the number one spot sharp.
Onana’s exit somewhat simplifies the competition but raises questions about United’s goalkeeping depth in the short term. With Bayindir now the main option and Lammens still acclimatising, there is greater pressure on the keeper to deliver.
Looking Ahead
Sunday’s match at City is likely to test not just the defence in front of Bayindir but also his mental resilience. Derbies bring intensity, scrutiny, and very fine margins. If Bayindir performs well, it could cement his claim to be United’s number one for the season. If he falters, doubts may resurface. Meanwhile, how Lammens responds to being second pick could set the tone for future selection battles.
In short, Amorim is sending a message: in key moments, experience will be favoured. But the underlying competition remains, and United’s goalkeeping future is still in the balance.
